How To Choose The Best Tomato

Large assortment of heirloom tomatoes

This article records the Peaceful Valley nursery’s tomato-growing and tasting project. For current selection advice by flavor, color, shape, and kitchen use, see Choosing the Perfect Tomato Variety.

For more on this topic, see Benefits of Removing Tomato Suckers in an Organic Garden.

Which Tomato Will You Choose For Your Garden?

There are so many varieties of tomatoes to choose from, Peaceful Valley has over 50 types of tomato seeds for sale! But how does one decide?

For more on this topic, see Patio Tomato Plants: Best Patio Tomato Varieties Guide Tips.

Well there are many things to consider such as where you live. If you live in a region with very short growing periods, consider growing varieties with shorter days to maturity. The Siberia or Stupice are varieties with shorter days to maturity (as short as 40 days).

If you have limited areas to grow your tomato plant or if you want one to put in a pot, a determinate variety is a tomato that you may want to select. Consider starting a Burbank or Siletz, both are determinate varieties, or a compact cherry tomato identified as suitable for containers on its current seed listing.

But really, the big question is, how do they taste? So the Peaceful Valley Tomato Project was born The nursery staff took on the project - start from seed and grow to maturity, every Peaceful Valley variety of tomato available!

Getting Started

Stupic tomato from PVFS Tomato Project

The project began back in the dreary and cold month of February by germinating the seeds in Quickroot placed in 6-packs. The seeds were warmed using a heat mat and tucked in with Agribon 50 to help retain the heat. After about one to two weeks the seeds began to germinate and grow. After the first set of true leaves were growing, the seedlings were watered once a week with a mixture of PVFS Liquid Fish and Maxicrop, a water-soluble dry kelp extract.

Moving Up

Once the seedlings had 3 to 4 sets of true leaves they were transplanted up into their own small pot using PVFS Potting Soil, making sure to soak the roots in a mixture of Maxicrop. The seedlings grew like crazy! I think the weekly feedings of fish/kelp mix really made the difference.

PVFS White Cherry tomato

About 4 weeks later, the plants were moved up to one gallon pots using the same recipe as before, PVFS Potting Soil and weekly feedings with fish and kelp.

Finally, the last chance of frost had past, around mid-May here in Grass Valley, CA, and the tomatoes were ready to go outside. The Peaceful Valley Nursery was soon overflowing with tomato plants.

Some were planted directly into the ground around the nursery and some potted into 5-gallon pulp pots containing, once again, our wonderful PVFS Potting Soil.

Bountiful Harvest

Summer finally was in full swing and so were the tomato plants in our project. We gathered up the ripe tomatoes and all the willing and hungry employees for a taste testing. Most varieties were rated very high and here are some responses:

PVFS Evergreen tomato

  • Black Prince - "mellow flavor, low acid"
  • Stupice - "good classic tomato flavor"
  • Black Krim - "nice smokey flavor"
  • Cherokee Purple - "one of my favorite tomatoes, nice flavor and firmness"
  • Evergreen - "the color of the tomato is a negative but the flavor is GREAT!"
  • Pink Brandywine - "so good I could eat it like an apple"
  • White Cherry - "really sweet, tastes like candy"

And the Winner is?

Well there were no clear winners in the taste test. Every tomato variety has its own unique qualities and every taster a unique palate. My advice is to try planting different varieties every year to decide for yourself which tomato is the best for your needs.

Do you want slicers, cherries, paste tomatoes or just a little of each?

PVFS Pink Brandywine tomato

Whatever variety of tomato you choose, schedule seed starting around your local frost dates and the seed packet’s lead time. The February start described above was for this Grass Valley project.

Next growing/tasting project... Peppers!

Conclusion

The Peaceful Valley Tomato Project showed us that growing tomatoes is about more than just a bountiful harvest—it’s also about discovering the unique flavors, colors, and characteristics that make each variety special. From the mellow flavor of Black Prince to the smoky taste of Black Krim and the sweetness of White Cherry, every tomato brought something different to the table.

Ultimately, there is no single best tomato for every garden or every palate. The right choice depends on your growing conditions, available space, growing season, and personal taste preferences. Whether you prefer juicy slicers, sweet cherry tomatoes, or flavorful paste varieties, experimenting with different types is one of the most enjoyable parts of gardening.

So, as you plan your next tomato garden, don’t be afraid to try something new! Choose varieties suited to your local climate, start your seeds at the right time, and enjoy the process from seed to harvest. You might just discover a new favorite along the way. After all, the best tomato is the one you love to grow—and love to eat!

FAQs About the Peaceful Valley Tomato Project

How do I choose the best tomato variety for my garden?
Consider your local climate, growing season, available space, and intended use. Check the seed packet for days to maturity and growth habit to find varieties suited to your garden.
Which tomato varieties are suitable for short growing seasons?
Early-maturing varieties may be suitable for short growing seasons. The article highlights ‘Siberia’ and ‘Stupice’ as options. Check current seed listings for maturity estimates, as actual harvest times depend on growing conditions.
Are determinate tomatoes suitable for containers?
Yes. Determinate tomatoes generally have a more compact, bush-like growth habit, making them suitable for containers. Choose a sufficiently large pot, provide adequate sunlight, and water consistently.
Which tomato varieties received positive reviews in the Peaceful Valley taste test?
The project recorded positive comments for several varieties, including ‘Black Krim’ for its smoky flavor, ‘Cherokee Purple’ for its flavor and firmness, ‘Pink Brandywine’ for its enjoyable taste, and ‘White Cherry’ for its sweetness. These were subjective observations from nursery staff, not a formal scientific taste trial.
When should I start tomato seeds?
Seed-starting time depends on your local climate, expected frost dates, and the variety’s recommended growing schedule. In regions with frost, seeds are commonly started indoors several weeks before outdoor transplanting. Follow the seed packet and local horticultural guidance rather than copying the article’s February schedule, which was specific to Grass Valley, California.
Back to blog

Related Products

1 of 5

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.